Volumetric breaks at mesh intersection

[phoenixart]

This is my first test with LuxCore Volumetrics, sorry if the solution has already been mentioned in the forum. I searched but no luck.
(Ignore the quality of the image, it's for testing purpose only)

Basically, I'm translating what I usually do in Cycles to Lux and I'm noticing something strange happening at the boundary of the ground plane.

This is the same scene roughly translated for Cycles

As you can see, the background in Cycles gets more muted and the ground blurs into the environment in a more, gradual way.
In LuxCore there's a sharp separation between the ground plane and the volumetric.

On top of that, the light has sharp edges (having the light visible doesn't fix the problem).

Here's my basic setup for the volumetric cube:

Any hints?

[FarbigeWelt]

This is my first test with LuxCore Volumetrics, sorry if the solution has already been mentioned in the forum. I searched but no luck.
(Ignore the quality of the image, it's for testing purpose only)

Any hints?

I usually define an external volume called Air.Clear.Volume.Prio.0 first. Then I define further volume, the internal volumes. In your case Air.Homo.Vol.Prio.10.

IOR are predefined in an utility node.

Then I set World volume and define Camera volume by choosing Air.Clear....

The camera should be located outside your cube with Material Null.

I hope this helps as a useful hint.

[Dade]

Any hints?

Your scene is likely to have a wrong setup: have you assigned a volume to the camera ? In alternative you can assign world volume.

[phoenixart]

It turns out everything works fine if the camera is positioned outside the volume as FarbigeWelt suggested.

Thanks!

[FarbigeWelt]

It turns out everything works fine if the camera is positioned outside the volume as FarbigeWelt suggested.

Thanks!

Thank you for your feedback.

[Dade]

It turns out everything works fine if the camera is positioned outside the volume as FarbigeWelt suggested.

It works also if it inside and you assign the volume to the camera.

[phoenixart]

It works also if it inside and you assign the volume to the camera.

Thanks for the heads up, Dade.

How do I do that?
Is it related to this?

Snipaste_2020-09-03_10-19-34.png (8.43 KiB) Viewed 3647 times

[B.Y.O.B.]

Yes. Disable auto-detection, and you will be able to specify the volume manually.
Auto-detection only works if the surface in the middle of the film has correct interior/exterior volumes assigned (e.g. in your case, fog as exterior volume). However since it can be annoying to go through all materials and specify the correct volumes, you can instead specify the camera volume manually.

[phoenixart]

Yes. Disable auto-detection, and you will be able to specify the volume manually.
Auto-detection only works if the surface in the middle of the film has correct interior/exterior volumes assigned (e.g. in your case, fog as exterior volume). However since it can be annoying to go through all materials and specify the correct volumes, you can instead specify the camera volume manually.

Thanks, B.Y.O.B.

I disabled the Auto-Detect, created a new Camera Volume which has these settings by default

And now I guess I can simply have my cube with the Homogeneous Volume extending past the camera.

Do I need to change any setting in the Camera Volume shader?
At the moment the result hasn't changed, I'm back to the clipping issue in the first image I posted.

[B.Y.O.B.]

If the camera is inside the fog, you need to set the fog volume as camera volume.
(it is the camera exterior volume)